American Reveille
  • Home
  • Bloggers
    • agent_smith.ai
    • Andrew Penn
    • Bryan Cornitius
    • Craig Brodsky
    • D.T. Osborn
    • Danelle Siegel
    • Dessica Leigh
    • Dr. Rafael Marrero
    • HuwJ
    • James Reichenbach
    • Jo Lee Irish
    • John Cylc
    See All Bloggers
  • Podcasts
    • A Couple of Hoosiers Podcast
    • American Reveille Podcast
  • The Hub

    Fox News

    Gateway Pundit

    The Daily Wire

    New York Post

    Breitbart News

    Newsmax

    Glenn Beck

    Dan Bongino

    Timcast IRL

    National File

    See All Websites
  • Video
  • TopicsHOT

    • Blogs
    • Business
    • Comedy
    • Education
    • Entertainment
    • Health
    • International
    • Law and Order
    • Money
    • Politics
    • Prepping
    • Real Estate
    • Religion
    • Science
    • Second Amendment
    • Woke World
    • Technology
    • Twitter Files
    • Speculation

  • Login
         
No Result
View All Result
HOT TOPICS
  • Blogs
  • Twitter Files
  • Woke World
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Money
  • Community
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • Bloggers
    • agent_smith.ai
    • Andrew Penn
    • Bryan Cornitius
    • Craig Brodsky
    • D.T. Osborn
    • Danelle Siegel
    • Dessica Leigh
    • Dr. Rafael Marrero
    • HuwJ
    • James Reichenbach
    • Jo Lee Irish
    • John Cylc
    See All Bloggers
  • Podcasts
    • A Couple of Hoosiers Podcast
    • American Reveille Podcast
  • The Hub

    Fox News

    Gateway Pundit

    The Daily Wire

    New York Post

    Breitbart News

    Newsmax

    Glenn Beck

    Dan Bongino

    Timcast IRL

    National File

    See All Websites
  • Video
  • TopicsHOT

    • Blogs
    • Business
    • Comedy
    • Education
    • Entertainment
    • Health
    • International
    • Law and Order
    • Money
    • Politics
    • Prepping
    • Real Estate
    • Religion
    • Science
    • Second Amendment
    • Woke World
    • Technology
    • Twitter Files
    • Speculation

No Result
View All Result
American Reveille
No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Twitter Files
  • Woke World

Renewable Power Gains, Costs, and Fantasies

Phil Nelson by Phil Nelson
Jan 10, 2023 2:14 am CST
in Phil Nelson, Science
0 0
A A
0
Renewable Power Gains, Costs, and Fantasies
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

“Modern” renewable energy sources made large gains in providing for global energy consumption over the ten years from 2009-19, according to a recent report, but that “headline” is highly misleading. So is a separate report on solar and wind power costs, which claims those sources are now cheaper than any fossil fuel. The underlying facts will receive little critical examination by a hopelessly naive press, nor among analysts with more technical wherewithal. Of course, “green” activists will go on using misinformation like this to have their way with policymakers.

Extinguishing Dung Fires

The “Renewables Global Status Report” was published in mid-June by an organization called REN21: Renewables Now. Francis Menton has a good discussion of the report on his blog, The Manhattan Contrarian. The big finding is a large increase in the global use of “modern” renewable energy sources, from 8.7% of total consumption in 2009 to 11.2% in 2019. The “modern” qualifier is critical: it distinguishes renewables that made gains from those that might be considered antiquated, like dung chips, the burning of which is an energy staple in many underdeveloped parts of the world. In fact, the share of those “non-modern renewables” declined from 11.0% to 8.7%, almost fully accounting for the displacement caused by “modern renewables.” The share of fossil fuels was almost unchanged, down from 80.3% in 2009 to 80.2% in 2019. Whatever the benefits of wind, solar, and other modern green power sources, they did not make much headway in displacing reliable fossil fuel energy.

I certainly can’t argue that replacing dung power with wind, solar, or hydro is a bad thing (but there are more sophisticated ways of converting dung to energy than open flame). However, I contend that replacing open dung fires with fossil-fuel or nuclear capacity would be better than renewables from both a cost and an environmental perspective. Be that as it may, the adoption of “modern renewables” over the ten-year period was not at the expense of fossil fuels, as might be expected if the latter was at a cost disadvantage, and remember that renewables were already given an edge via intense government efforts to subsidize and even require the use of wind and solar power.

The near-term limits on our ability to substitute renewables for fossil fuels should be fairly obvious. For one thing, renewable power is intermittent, so it cannot be relied upon for baseload generation. The chart at the top of this post demonstrates this reality, though the chart is “optimistic” in the sense that planners have to consider worst-case intermittency, not merely average production by time-of-day. Reliable power sources must be maintained in order to prevent the kinds of disasters like we saw in Texas last winter when demand spiked and output from renewables plunged. This is an area of considerable denialism: a search on “intermittent renewables” gets you an unending list of rosy assessments of energy storage technologies, and very little realistic commentary on today’s needs for meeting baseload or weather-induced demands.

While renewables account for about 29% of global electricity generation, there is another limit on adoption: certain jobs just can’t be done with renewables short of major advances in battery technology. As Menton says:

“Steel mills and tractor trailer trucks and airplanes powered by solar panels? Not happening. … I think these people really believe that if governments will just do the right thing and require airplanes to run on solar panels, then it will promptly happen.“

Cost and Intermittency

Again, we’d expect to see more rapid conversion to renewable energy, at least in compatible applications, as the cost of renewables drops relative to fossil fuels. And major components of their costs have indeed dropped, so much so that the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) now says they are cheaper than fossil fuels in terms of the “levelized cost” of new electric generating capacity. That’s the average cost per megawatt-hour produced over the life of a new installation. The EIA’s calculations are distorted on at least two counts, however, as Willis Eschenbach ably explains here.

The EIA’s cost figures reflect a “capacity factor” that adjusts the megawatts produced to presumed “real world” conditions. It’s more like a utilization adjustment made necessary by a variety of realities (intermittency as well as other technical imperfections) that cause output to run lower than the maximum under ideal conditions. Eschenbach reports that the factors applied by the EIA for solar and wind, at 30% and 41%, respectively, are overstated drastically, which reduces their cost estimates by overstating output. For solar, he cites a more realistic value of 14%, which would more than double the levelized cost of solar. For wind, he quotes a figure of 30%, which would increase the cost of wind power by more than a third. That puts the cost of those renewables well above that of a “combined-cycle gas” plant, which uses exhaust from gas turbines to generate additional power via steam.

The true costs of renewables are likely much higher than nuclear power as well, based on earlier comparisons of nuclear to combined-cycle gas. The EIA does not report a cost for nuclear power, however, because the report is for new capacity, and no additions of nuclear capacity are expected.

The Cost of Back-Up Capacity

Eschenbach notes a second major problem with the EIA cost comparisons. As discussed above, the intermittency of solar and wind power means that their deployment cannot provide for base loads. Other, “dispatchable” power technologies, on which production can be ramped up or down at discretion, must be available to meet power needs when renewables are off-line, as is frequently the case. The more we attempt to rely on renewables, the more significant the intermittency problem becomes, as Germany, Texas, and California are discovering.

How to account for the extra cost of dispatchable power required to smooth production or meet peak demand? Renewables are simply incapable of doing so reliably, and back-up capacity ain’t free! Meeting demand at all times requires equivalent dispatchable capacity in the power mix. It requires not just dispatchable baseload capacity, but surge capacity! Meeting long-term growth in demand with renewables implies that new back-up capacity is required as well, and the levelized cost should reflect it. After all, those costs won’t be saved by virtue of adding renewable capacity, unless you plan on blackouts. Thus, the EIA’s levelized cost comparisons of wind, solar and fossil fuel electricity generation are completely phony.

Conclusion

Growth in wind and solar power increased their contribution to global energy needs to more than 11% in 2019, but their gains over the previous ten years came largely at the expense of more “primitive” renewable energy sources, not fossil fuels. And despite impressive declines in the installation costs of wind and solar power, and despite low variable costs, the economics of power generation still favors fossil fuels rather substantially. In popular discussions, this point is often obscured by the heavy subsidies granted to renewables.

In truth, the “name-plate” capacities of wind and solar installations far exceed typical output, so installation costs are spread over less output than is widely believed. Furthermore, the intermittency of production from these renewable sources means that back-up capacity is still required, almost always from plants fired by fossil fuels. Properly considered, this represents a significant incremental cost of renewable power sources, but it is one that is routinely ignored by environmentalists and even in official reports. It’s also worth noting that “modern” renewables carry significant external costs to the environment both during the useful life of the plant and at disposal (and see here). It’s tempting to say all these distortions and omissions are deliberate contributions to the propaganda in favor of government mandates for renewables.

Read: The Left Always Hurts the Ones They “Love,” by Flipper Doggie

  • Phil Nelson
    Phil Nelson
ShareTweetPinShareShareSendSend
Phil Nelson

Phil Nelson

Contributor

Related Articles

EXCLUSIVE – How to tell if your ‘online romance’ is really an artificial intelligence SCAMMER: Expert reveals the seven signs your love interest is a chatbot designed to steal your money
Science

EXCLUSIVE – How to tell if your ‘online romance’ is really an artificial intelligence SCAMMER: Expert reveals the seven signs your love interest is a chatbot designed to steal your money

Mar 26, 2023 11:16 pm CDT
Why you should NEVER share your Wi-Fi password with friends – these 10 reasons will make you think twice
Science

Why you should NEVER share your Wi-Fi password with friends – these 10 reasons will make you think twice

Mar 26, 2023 8:15 pm CDT
Look up this week! FIVE planets will be visible in the night sky on Tuesday evening – here’s how to see Jupiter, Mercury, Venus, Uranus and Mars
Science

Look up this week! FIVE planets will be visible in the night sky on Tuesday evening – here’s how to see Jupiter, Mercury, Venus, Uranus and Mars

Mar 26, 2023 5:12 pm CDT
EXCLUSIVE: ‘Half of school and college students are already using ChatGPT to cheat’: Experts warn AI tech should strike fear in all academics
Science

EXCLUSIVE: ‘Half of school and college students are already using ChatGPT to cheat’: Experts warn AI tech should strike fear in all academics

Mar 26, 2023 2:09 pm CDT
Bottle or can? Scientists finally settle the debate on which vessels keep BEER fresher for longer – with surprising results
Science

Bottle or can? Scientists finally settle the debate on which vessels keep BEER fresher for longer – with surprising results

Mar 26, 2023 11:08 am CDT
Five legendary UFO sightings that still puzzle observers (and what experts think REALLY happened)
Science

Five legendary UFO sightings that still puzzle observers (and what experts think REALLY happened)

Mar 26, 2023 8:04 am CDT
Unravelling the mystery of Tutankhamun: Five unanswered questions about Ancient Egypt’s Boy King – including how he died and whether there’s more to find in his tomb
Science

Unravelling the mystery of Tutankhamun: Five unanswered questions about Ancient Egypt’s Boy King – including how he died and whether there’s more to find in his tomb

Mar 26, 2023 5:03 am CDT
Planning to change the clocks tonight? You’re obeying the nanny state, time expert claims
Science

Planning to change the clocks tonight? You’re obeying the nanny state, time expert claims

Mar 26, 2023 2:00 am CDT
The Japanese mountain that is a magnet for UFOs: Remote village says it is a ‘home to aliens’ after repeated mysterious sightings over four decades
Science

The Japanese mountain that is a magnet for UFOs: Remote village says it is a ‘home to aliens’ after repeated mysterious sightings over four decades

Mar 25, 2023 10:56 pm CDT

Discussion about this post

Recommended Stories

Miami Beach Declares State Of Emergency as Thugs Target Spring Break

Miami Beach Declares State Of Emergency as Thugs Target Spring Break

Mar 27, 2023 12:01 am CDT
Harry Styles called Emily Ratajkowski his ‘celebrity crush’ in a throwback video taken eight years prior to their passionate kiss

Harry Styles called Emily Ratajkowski his ‘celebrity crush’ in a throwback video taken eight years prior to their passionate kiss

Mar 26, 2023 11:24 pm CDT
Philadelphia Trial Program to Pay Pregnant Women $1K Per Month

Philadelphia Trial Program to Pay Pregnant Women $1K Per Month

Mar 26, 2023 11:14 pm CDT
It's Getting Ugly Out There

It's Getting Ugly Out There

Mar 26, 2023 11:13 pm CDT
Son of Gulf Cartel Kingpin Gets U.S. Prison Time on Gun Trafficking Charges

Son of Gulf Cartel Kingpin Gets U.S. Prison Time on Gun Trafficking Charges

Mar 26, 2023 11:12 pm CDT

The government and mainstream media are lying to you.

Be the first to get the latest real news and entertainment directly to your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

Popular Stories

  • Ford Pauses Shipping, Building Electric F-150 Model Due to Potential Battery Issue

    Electric Vehicles Bleeding Red Ink: Ford Is Losing Billions on EVs

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • US intelligence destroyed Nord Stream pipelines – Putin

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Slovakia delivers first four Soviet-era MiG-29 jets to Ukraine

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • ‘Invisible Boogeyman Of Systematic Racism’: Black Mom Shreds Minnesota ‘Ethnic Studies’ Bill, Slams Woke Nonsense

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Big Brother: Local Govt to Deploy Drones to Monitor Property Zoning Compliance

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
American Reveille

American Reveille provides a platform for independent journalists and amateur bloggers to share their perspectives on political and social issues, with a focus on representing the views of a balanced, center-right audience. The website offers a mix of original content and aggregated news, as well as AI-generated content, with the goal of raising awareness about the challenges facing America. Overall, the brand of americanreveille.com is focused on serving as a "wake-up call" for its audience, encouraging them to engage with and think critically about the issues facing the country.

Recent News

  • Miami Beach Declares State Of Emergency as Thugs Target Spring Break
  • Harry Styles called Emily Ratajkowski his ‘celebrity crush’ in a throwback video taken eight years prior to their passionate kiss
  • EXCLUSIVE – How to tell if your ‘online romance’ is really an artificial intelligence SCAMMER: Expert reveals the seven signs your love interest is a chatbot designed to steal your money

Hot Topics

Breitbart NewsBusinessDan BonginoEntertainmentFox NewsGateway PunditHealthInternationalLaw and OrderNewsmaxNew York PostPoliticsPreppingScienceThe Daily WireTimcast IRLVideo

Get Informed

The government and mainstream media are lying to you.

Be the first to get the latest real news and entertainment directly to your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

  • About
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Press Release
  • Advertise
  • Contact

Copyright © 2023 American Reveille - Created by Sawah Solutions.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Bloggers
  • Podcasts
    • A Couple of Hoosiers Podcast
    • American Reveille Podcast
  • The Hub
  • Video
  • Topics
  • Blogs
  • Business
  • Comedy
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • International
  • Law and Order
  • Money
  • Politics
  • Prepping
  • Real Estate
  • Religion
  • Science
  • Speculation
  • Twitter Files
  • Woke World

Copyright © 2023 American Reveille - Created by Sawah Solutions.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?