American Reveille
  • Home
  • Bloggers
    • agent_smith.ai
    • Ali Asif
    • Andrew Penn
    • Bryan Cornitius
    • Craig Brodsky
    • D.T. Osborn
    • Danelle Siegel
    • Dessica Leigh
    • Dr. Rafael Marrero
    • Blessing Halim
    • HuwJ
    • James Reichenbach
    See All Bloggers
  • Podcasts
    • A Couple of Hoosiers Podcast
    • American Reveille Podcast
  • The Hub

    Fox News

    Gateway Pundit

    The Daily Wire

    New York Post

    Breitbart News

    Newsmax

    Glenn Beck

    Dan Bongino

    Timcast IRL

    National File

    See All Websites
  • Video
  • TopicsHOT

    • Blogs
    • Business
    • Comedy
    • Education
    • Entertainment
    • Health
    • International
    • Law and Order
    • Money
    • Politics
    • Prepping
    • Real Estate
    • Religion
    • Science
    • Second Amendment
    • Woke World
    • Technology
    • Twitter Files
    • Speculation

  • Login
         
No Result
View All Result
HOT TOPICS
  • Blogs
  • Twitter Files
  • Woke World
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Money
  • Community
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • Bloggers
    • agent_smith.ai
    • Ali Asif
    • Andrew Penn
    • Bryan Cornitius
    • Craig Brodsky
    • D.T. Osborn
    • Danelle Siegel
    • Dessica Leigh
    • Dr. Rafael Marrero
    • Blessing Halim
    • HuwJ
    • James Reichenbach
    See All Bloggers
  • Podcasts
    • A Couple of Hoosiers Podcast
    • American Reveille Podcast
  • The Hub

    Fox News

    Gateway Pundit

    The Daily Wire

    New York Post

    Breitbart News

    Newsmax

    Glenn Beck

    Dan Bongino

    Timcast IRL

    National File

    See All Websites
  • Video
  • TopicsHOT

    • Blogs
    • Business
    • Comedy
    • Education
    • Entertainment
    • Health
    • International
    • Law and Order
    • Money
    • Politics
    • Prepping
    • Real Estate
    • Religion
    • Science
    • Second Amendment
    • Woke World
    • Technology
    • Twitter Files
    • Speculation

No Result
View All Result
American Reveille
No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Twitter Files
  • Woke World

Censorship and Content Moderation In the Public Square

Phil Nelson by Phil Nelson
Jan 10, 2023 2:14 am CST
in Featured, Phil Nelson, Technology
0 0
A A
0
Censorship and Content Moderation In the Public Square
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

I’m probably as fed up with social media as anyone, given the major platforms’ penchant for censoring on the basis of politics, scientific debate, religion, and posting while “unwoke.” I quit Facebook back in January and haven’t regretted it. It’s frustratingly difficult to convince others to give it up, however, andI’ve tried! Ultimately, major user defections would provide the most effective means of restraining the company’s power.

Beyond my wild fantasies of a consumer revolt, I have a visceral desire to see the dominant social media platforms emasculated in some way: broken up, regulated, or even fined for complaints of censorial action. That feeling is reinforced by their anti-competitive behavior, which is difficult to curb.

Are There Better Ways

While my gut says we need drastic action by government, my head tells me … not … so … fast! These are private companies, after all. I’m an adherent of free markets and private property, so I cannot abide government intrusions to force anyone to sponsor speech they find objectionable using their private facilities. At the same time, however, our free speech rights must be protected in the “public square,” and the social media companies have long claimed that their platforms offer a modern form of that open square. If they can be taken at their word, should there be some remedy available against such a business to those denied a voice based upon their point-of-view? This seems especially pertinent when access to “public accommodations” is so critical to the meaning of non-discrimination under current law (not that I personally believe businesses in general should be forced to accommodate the specific desires of all comers).

In a lengthy and scholarly treatment of “Treating Social Media Platforms Like Common Carriers,”Eugene Volokh states the following about U.S. Supreme Court case law (pg. 41):

“Under PruneYard and Rumsfeld, private property owners who open up their property to the public (or to some segment of the public, such as military recruiters) may be required by state or federal law to share their real estate with other speakers.”

The Common Carrier Solution

Volokh’s article is very detailed and informative. I highly recommend it to anyone hoping to gain an understanding of the complex legal issues associated with the rights of big tech firms, their users, and other interested parties. His article highlights the long-standing legal principle that so-called “common carriers” in telecommunications cannot discriminate on the basis of speech.

Volokh believes it would be reasonable and constitutional to treat the big social media platforms as common carriers. Then, the platforms would be prohibited from discriminating based on viewpoint, though free to recommend material to their users. He also puts forward a solution that would essentially permit social media firms to continue to receive protection from liability for user posts like that granted under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act:

“… I think Congress could categorically treat platforms as common carriers, at least as to their hosting function. But Congress could also constitutionally give platforms two options as to any of their functions: (1) Claim common carrier status, which will let them be like phone companies, immune from liability but also required to host all viewpoints, or (2) be distributors like bookstores, free to pick and choose what to host but subject to liability (at least on a notice-and-takedown basis).”

Economist Luigi Zingales emphasizes the formidable network externalities that give the incumbent platforms like Facebook a dominance that is almost unshakable. Zingales essentially agrees with Volokh, but he refers to common carrier status for what he calls the “sharing function” with Section 230-like protections, while the so-called “editing function” can and should be competitive. Zingales calls recommendations of material by a platform part of the editing function which should not be granted protection from liability. In that last sense, his emphasis differs somewhat from Volokh’s. However, both seem to think a change in the law is necessary to allow protections where they serve the “public interest,” as opposed to merely protecting the private interests of the platforms.

The most destructive aspect of Section 230 immunity is the so-called “Good Samaritan” clause aimed at various kinds of offensive material (“… obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable, whether or not such material is constitutionally protected.”), which the social media platforms have used as “a license to censor,” as Philip Hamburger puts it. Here, Eugene Volokh and others, including Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, assert that this provision should not receive a broad interpretation in determining immunity for content moderation decisions. In other words, the phrase “otherwise objectionable” in the provision must be interpreted within the context of the statute, which, after all, has to do with communications decency! (Here again, I question whether the government has any business authorizing censorship of any form.)

Arm of Government?

Viewpoint discrimination and censorship by the platforms is bad enough, but in addition, by all appearances, there is a danger of allowing companies like Facebook to become unofficial speech control ministries in the service of various governments around the world, including the U.S. Here is Vivek Ramaswamy’s astute take on the matter:

“… Facebook likely serves increasingly as the censorship arm of the US government, just as it does for other governments around the world.

In countries like India, Israel, Thailand, and Vietnam, Facebook frequently removes posts at the behest of the government to deter regulatory reprisal. Here at home, we know that Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg regularly correspond with US officials, ranging from e-mail exchanges with Dr. Anthony Fauci on COVID-19 policy to discussing “problematic posts” that “spread disinformation” with the White House.

If Zuckerberg and Sandberg are also directly making decisions about which posts to censor versus permit, that makes it much more likely that they are responsive to the threats and inducements from government officials.”

Even LinkedIn has censored journalists in China who have produced stories the government finds unflattering. Money comes first, I guess! I’m all for the profit motive, but it should never take precedence over fundamental human rights like free speech.

There is no question of a First Amendment violation if Facebook or any other platform is censoring users on behalf of the U.S. government, and Section 230 immunity would be null and void under those circumstances.

Elections … Their Way

On the other hand, we also know that platforms repeatedly censored distribution of the Trump Administration’s viewpoints; like them or not, we’re talking about officials of the executive branch of the U.S. government! This raises the possibility that Section 230 immunity was (or should have been) vitiated by attempts to silence the government. And of course, there is no question that the social media platforms sought to influence the 2020 election via curation of posts, but it is not clear whether that is currently within their rights under Section 230’s Good Samaritan clause. Some would note the danger to fair elections inherent in any platform’s willingness to appease authoritarian governments around the world, or their willingness and ability to influence U.S. elections.

Pledge of Facebook Allegiance

Some of our domestic social media companies have become supra-national entities without a shred of loyalty to the U.S. This article in The Atlantic, of all places, is entitled “The Largest Autocracy on Earth, “and it has a sub-heading that says it all:

“Facebook is acting like a hostile foreign power; it’s time we treated it that way.”

The article reports that Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg has promoted the mantra “company over country.” That should disabuse you of any notion that he cares one whit about the ideals embodied in the U.S. Constitution. He is a child consumed with dominance, control, and profit for his enterprise, and he might be a megalomaniac to boot. If he wants to host social media relationships in this country, let’s make Facebook a common carrier hosting platform.

Read: Taxing the Poor Through Inflation: The Democrat Master Con-Job, by Phil Nelson

  • Phil Nelson
    Phil Nelson
Tags: american reveilleanthony faucibig tech censorshipblogcensorshipcensorship articlesClarance ThomasCommon CarrierCommunications Decency ActEugene VolokhFacebookfirst amendmentGood Samaritan ProvisionHosting FunctionLinkedInLuigi ZingalesMark ZuckerbergPhilip HamburgerPublic AccommodationsSection 230 ImmunitySheryl Sandbergsupreme courttechnologyTrump AdministrationVivek Ramaswamy
ShareTweetPinShareShareSendSend
Phil Nelson

Phil Nelson

Contributor

Related Articles

Technology

China’s Greatest Weapon: TikTok Pushes Suicide Videos on 13-Year-Olds

Mar 22, 2023 3:23 pm CDT
Technology

Report: Tesla Crashes Increased After Elon Musk Removed Radar Sensors from Cars

Mar 22, 2023 12:20 pm CDT
Leftists and Congressional Republicans Agree: Government Witness in Mackey Case Is ‘Full of It’
Technology

Leftists and Congressional Republicans Agree: Government Witness in Mackey Case Is ‘Full of It’

Mar 22, 2023 9:19 am CDT
Technology

WSJ: State Government Websites Are Infested with Trackers from China’s TikTok

Mar 22, 2023 6:16 am CDT
TikTok Finds Ally in Democrat Rep. Jamaal Bowman amid Calls to Ban the Chinese-Controlled Platform
Technology

TikTok Finds Ally in Democrat Rep. Jamaal Bowman amid Calls to Ban the Chinese-Controlled Platform

Mar 22, 2023 3:12 am CDT
Silicon Valley Bank Employees Think Remote Work Contributed to Collapse
Technology

Silicon Valley Bank Employees Think Remote Work Contributed to Collapse

Mar 21, 2023 9:05 pm CDT
40k+ Western New York Women Joined a Facebook Group to Detect Infidelity, ‘Toxic Men’
Technology

40k+ Western New York Women Joined a Facebook Group to Detect Infidelity, ‘Toxic Men’

Mar 21, 2023 6:01 pm CDT
Amazon to Lay Off 9,000 *More* Employees After Cutting 18,000 in November
Technology

Amazon to Lay Off 9,000 *More* Employees After Cutting 18,000 in November

Mar 21, 2023 1:20 pm CDT
Technology

Woke Vs. Woke: Google Employees Upset over Company’s Layoffs

Mar 21, 2023 10:17 am CDT

Discussion about this post

Recommended Stories

‘I challenge myself’: Jennifer Lopez, 53, says exercise is ‘important’ as it improves mental health… after revealing she wakes up at 4:45AM to work out

‘I challenge myself’: Jennifer Lopez, 53, says exercise is ‘important’ as it improves mental health… after revealing she wakes up at 4:45AM to work out

Mar 22, 2023 4:20 pm CDT
Banks Begin Calling Customers To Ask For Loans

Banks Begin Calling Customers To Ask For Loans

Mar 22, 2023 4:15 pm CDT
Rainy Solo Hammock Camp on an E-Bike

Rainy Solo Hammock Camp on an E-Bike

Mar 22, 2023 4:15 pm CDT
Bill Gates Says ‘The Age Of AI Has Begun’

Bill Gates Says ‘The Age Of AI Has Begun’

Mar 22, 2023 3:38 pm CDT
How YOU can harness ChatGPT without being a tech whiz: From applying for jobs to choosing a weight-loss program, our easy step-by-step guide walks you through the powers of the AI

How YOU can harness ChatGPT without being a tech whiz: From applying for jobs to choosing a weight-loss program, our easy step-by-step guide walks you through the powers of the AI

Mar 22, 2023 3:37 pm CDT

The government and mainstream media are lying to you.

Be the first to get the latest real news and entertainment directly to your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

Popular Stories

  • ‘It’s out of control and dangerous’: Furious California residents rage at prostitutes being allowed to linger on streets – with women in thongs on street corners, twerking at traffic and pimps following mothers to school after Gov. Newsom passed woke laws

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Media Mogul David Geffen, 80, Marries 30-Year-Old Boyfriend

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Police: Father Accused of Having 900 Child Porn Images After Wife Finds Hidden Camera

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Watch: Teacher Tells Kindergartners ‘When Babies Are Born,’ Doctors ‘Guess Whether the Baby Is a Boy or a Girl’

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Navy Renames Two Ships to Erase Ties to Confederate History

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
American Reveille

American Reveille provides a platform for independent journalists and amateur bloggers to share their perspectives on political and social issues, with a focus on representing the views of a balanced, center-right audience. The website offers a mix of original content and aggregated news, as well as AI-generated content, with the goal of raising awareness about the challenges facing America. Overall, the brand of americanreveille.com is focused on serving as a "wake-up call" for its audience, encouraging them to engage with and think critically about the issues facing the country.

Recent News

  • ‘I challenge myself’: Jennifer Lopez, 53, says exercise is ‘important’ as it improves mental health… after revealing she wakes up at 4:45AM to work out
  • Banks Begin Calling Customers To Ask For Loans
  • Rainy Solo Hammock Camp on an E-Bike

Hot Topics

Breitbart NewsBusinessDan BonginoEntertainmentFox NewsGateway PunditHealthInternationalLaw and OrderNewsmaxNew York PostPoliticsPreppingScienceThe Daily WireTimcast IRLVideo

Get Informed

The government and mainstream media are lying to you.

Be the first to get the latest real news and entertainment directly to your inbox.

By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

  • About
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Press Release
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Sitemaps 1
  • Sitemaps 2
  • Sitemaps 3
  • Sitemap 4

Copyright © 2023 American Reveille - Created by Sawah Solutions.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Bloggers
  • Podcasts
    • A Couple of Hoosiers Podcast
    • American Reveille Podcast
  • The Hub
  • Video
  • Topics
  • Blogs
  • Business
  • Comedy
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • International
  • Law and Order
  • Money
  • Politics
  • Prepping
  • Real Estate
  • Religion
  • Science
  • Speculation
  • Twitter Files
  • Woke World

Copyright © 2023 American Reveille - Created by Sawah Solutions.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?